Santa Claus Indiana Real Estate & Homes for Sale

You have arrived on our Santa Claus real estate website including Real Estate In Santa Claus. Here you will be able to search all homes for sale in the Santa Claus Indiana real estate MLS. This includes all Santa Claus IN properties for sale such as condominiums, homes and houses and also includes short-sales, foreclosures and HUD Homes. If you are ready to buy or sell a house, we can help you out as a Santa Claus Indiana real estate agent which includes Real Estate In Santa Claus. If you see a house you want more information on or would like to schedule a showing, be sure to call The Charlie Butler Team, a great Santa Claus IN Realtor, at 812-422-4096. If you would like to buy a new Santa Claus IN home, we can get you in contact with Santa Claus IN home builders to see all of your Santa Claus home construction options including Real Estate In Santa Claus. Our Free MLS Search includes all Multi-Family, Residential, Land and Commercial Listings for sale in Santa Claus IN.

Contact: The Charlie Butler Team
701 N. Weinbach Suite 610
Evansville, IN, 47711
812-422-4096

Newest Santa Clause Homes for Sale

458 Evergreen Plaza N, Santa Claus IN 47579

$299,500

458 Evergreen Plaza N, Santa Claus

This home is immaculate and in a great neighborhood. Come see this brick home on two lots in the Evergreen Subdivision. It is a lakeview home with an amazing salt water...

  • Beds 4
  • Baths 4.0
  • MLS 201431148

$159,900

1055 Holly Drive, Santa Claus

Amazing home in walking distance of Holly Park. This brick ranch has an amazing wow factor as your enter the front door and admire the 14 ft ceilings and arched entryway ...

  • Beds 3
  • Baths 2.0
  • MLS 201419367

771 Melchoir Dr. N, Santa Claus IN 47579

$149,900

771 Melchoir Dr. N, Santa Claus

WOW!! This new listing is a must see rare find. Three bedrooms and 2 bath home with lots of up grades only 6 years old and 1 owner. Incredible extensive landscaping. ...

  • Beds 3
  • Baths 2.0
  • MLS 201431299

$80,000

19 Cedar Lane, Santa Claus

Vacant Commercial land 80' x 308' with small pond

  • Beds
  • Baths
  • MLS 201431119

735 Noel E, Santa Claus IN 47579

$129,900

735 Noel E, Santa Claus

Adorable ranch on a quiet street near Lake Noel. Home features 3 bedroom and 2 bath. Family and Master bedroom have tray ceilings. Flooring is carpet and tile floors. ...

  • Beds 3
  • Baths 2.0
  • MLS 201430640

930 Melody Lane, Santa Claus IN 47579

$119,000

930 Melody Lane, Santa Claus

Great Value for the Price - Located across the Street from the Golf Course this Brick Ranch Home has 1,518 sq. ft. of living area - 3 BRs. - 2 full baths - 2 car garage -...

  • Beds 3
  • Baths 2.0
  • MLS 201430342

56 Joy Circle, Santa Claus IN 47579

$253,900

56 Joy Circle, Santa Claus

This Beautiful Brick Home with walk-out basement in two lots in secluded cul-de-sac on three lots in Garted Community of Christmas Lake Village has 3,466 sq. ft. of livin...

  • Beds 3
  • Baths 3.0
  • MLS 201429788

645 Ornament Circle, Santa Claus IN 47579

$254,000

645 Ornament Circle, Santa Claus

Beautiful Brick Ranch Home on two lots on Lake Holly in Gated Community on cul-de-sac. Home is beautifully landscaped and ready for your Family. Home has 10' x 12' outb...

  • Beds 3
  • Baths 3.0
  • MLS 201429678

69 Blue Spruce Dr, Santa Claus IN 47579

$110,000

69 Blue Spruce Dr, Santa Claus

***1 Lakefront Lot on Christmas Lake*** Located near front gate in Evergreen Subdivision. Enjoy All of The Fabulous Amenities of Christmas Lake Village Including 3 Lakes ...

  • Beds
  • Baths
  • MLS 201429082

578 Ornament E, Santa Claus IN 47579

$104,900

578 Ornament E, Santa Claus

This home is located on a large corner lot. The house offers wood and tile floors with carpet in the bedrooms. The basement has been b-dryed with a warranty in the file t...

  • Beds 3
  • Baths 2.0
  • MLS 201428925

1028 Star Cir, Santa Claus IN 47579

$231,900

1028 Star Cir, Santa Claus

Another beautiful home by Smith Homes. 1850 sq.ft. with view of Lake Noel. 3 bedrooms, 2 1/2 baths, 3 car garage. Granite countertops, stainless steel kitchen appliances,...

  • Beds 3
  • Baths 3.0
  • MLS 201427717

740 Sled Run, Santa Claus IN 47579

$152,900

740 Sled Run, Santa Claus

Nice bi-level home located in Christmas Lake Village on Lake Holly. Located on 1 1/2 lots with mature trees for great shade. Three bedrooms, 2 full remodeled baths with...

  • Beds 3
  • Baths 2.0
  • MLS 201427756

989 Balthazar Dr, Santa Claus IN 47579

$1,000

989 Balthazar Dr, Santa Claus

***1 Lot in Christmas Lake*** Enjoy All of The Fabulous Amenities of Christmas Lake Village Including 3 Lakes (Christmas Lake, Lake Holly, & Lake Noel), a Beach/Swimming...

  • Beds
  • Baths
  • MLS 201427576

955 Rudolph Lane, Santa Claus IN 47579

$145,000

955 Rudolph Lane, Santa Claus

Very nice floor plan and open spaces complete this brick ranch home with island in the kitchen, split bedrooms and 12x12 screened-in porch.

  • Beds 3
  • Baths 2.0
  • MLS 201427221

$5,000

Melchoir Dr, Santa Claus

Nice lot near the new gate 4th lot E of the intersection of Kasper & Melchoir N

  • Beds
  • Baths
  • MLS 201427078

523 Star  Drive, Santa Claus IN 47579

$149,900

523 Star Drive, Santa Claus

All brick ranch on a level lot near golf course. Enter through a covered front porch into a tray ceiling family room. Enjoy the large sun room off the back of house wit...

  • Beds 3
  • Baths 2.0
  • MLS 201426804

579 Ornament E, Santa Claus IN 47579

$149,500

579 Ornament E, Santa Claus

Welcome home. You will appreciate all that this 3 bedroom home has to offer. Centrally located in beautiful Christmas Lake Village for the feel of vacation year round. ...

  • Beds 3
  • Baths 2.0
  • MLS 201424697

452 Balthazar Dr., Santa Claus IN 47579

$389,900

452 Balthazar Dr., Santa Claus

Amazing 4 Bedroom, 3 1/2 Bath home with incredible lake views of the big lake in Christmas Lake Village. This all brick home offers a concrete driveway and a rear load...

  • Beds 4
  • Baths 4.0
  • MLS 201424470

1027 Melchoir Drive, Santa Claus IN 47579

$272,000

1027 Melchoir Drive, Santa Claus

This gorgeous 4 bedroom with 3.5 bath home a waits you, Full basement. Total square feet is 3400, there is 1250 sq ft on main level and 1250 sq ft basement, and 900 sq ft...

  • Beds 4
  • Baths 4.0
  • MLS 201424604

501 Mariah Dr Unit 27, Santa Claus IN 47579

$4,900

501 Mariah Dr Unit 27, Santa Claus

Seller is willing to trade for other chattels(4wheelers, tractors,etc.)

  • Beds
  • Baths
  • MLS 201424139

1000 Star Cir, Santa Claus IN 47579

$199,900

1000 Star Cir, Santa Claus

Incredible Aframe home on Lake Noel. House is in great shape and on a large cul-de-sac lakefront lot on Lake Noel. The view is incredible of the full lake. You have views...

  • Beds 3
  • Baths 2.0
  • MLS 201423798

637 Sled Run, Santa Claus IN 47579

$137,000

637 Sled Run, Santa Claus

Beautiful 3-4 bedroom home situated on a large lot surrounded by a woods. This home has large rooms with a bonus den area that overlooks large deck and huge backyard. As ...

  • Beds 3
  • Baths 2.0
  • MLS 201423542

967 Sled Circle, Santa Claus IN 47579

$19,900

967 Sled Circle, Santa Claus

*****Lakefront of Lake Noel. Great Location on Cu-del-sac.***** Enjoy All of The Fabulous Amenities of Christmas Lake Village Including 3 Lakes (Christmas Lake, Lake Ho...

  • Beds
  • Baths
  • MLS 201423154

536 Star Drive, Santa Claus IN 47579

$246,500

536 Star Drive, Santa Claus

Awesome roomy salt box style home complete with a formal dining room, across the entry into the formal living room and through the double doors to the cozy family room wi...

  • Beds 4
  • Baths 4.0
  • MLS 201422919

141 Blue Spruce Dr. Santa Claus, Santa Claus IN 47579

$448,900

141 Blue Spruce Dr. Santa Claus, Santa Claus

Location, Location, Location Don't miss this supreme location on the Big Lake at Christmas Lake Village.. This beautiful, 217 Acre lakefront home has so much to offer. ...

  • Beds 4
  • Baths 5.0
  • MLS 201421386

679 Sleigh Bell Dr, Santa Claus IN 47579

$229,000

679 Sleigh Bell Dr, Santa Claus

This Brick Ranch home is located on 1 1/2 golf course lots on cul-de-sac. great view of # 4 and # 5 golf course. Two sided fireplace in Living/family room. 6 panel door, ...

  • Beds
  • Baths 2.0
  • MLS 201420539

153 Melchior Dr Unit 66, Santa Claus IN 47579

$4,500

153 Melchior Dr Unit 66, Santa Claus

Nice wooded lot with views of lake and golf course

  • Beds
  • Baths
  • MLS 201420409

Pine Tree, Santa Claus IN 47579

$3,000

Pine Tree, Santa Claus

Got building lot, are just to gain entry to the Village. Enjoy fishing, boating, the Rec center, golf, the beach.

  • Beds
  • Baths
  • MLS 201420091

578 Dasher Lane, Santa Claus IN 47579

$5,000

578 Dasher Lane, Santa Claus

Near new gate and on level wooded lot. Enjoy All of The Fabulous Amenities of Christmas Lake Village Including 3 Lakes (Christmas Lake, Lake Holly, & Lake Noel), a Beach...

  • Beds
  • Baths
  • MLS 201419165

556 Dasher Lane, Santa Claus IN 47579

$5,000

556 Dasher Lane, Santa Claus

Located near new gate and backs up to farm land. Enjoy All of The Fabulous Amenities of Christmas Lake Village Including 3 Lakes (Christmas Lake, Lake Holly, & Lake Noel)...

  • Beds
  • Baths
  • MLS 201419168

945 December 25, Santa Claus IN 47579

$219,900

945 December 25, Santa Claus

View this brick home with beautiful landscaping near the golf course in the private gated community of Christmas Lake Village. The house features vaulted ceilings with a ...

  • Beds 4
  • Baths 3.0
  • MLS 201418727

275 Melchoir Dr. W., Santa Claus IN 47579

$262,500

275 Melchoir Dr. W., Santa Claus

Awesome wooded setting with creeks and little bridge on this large brick home with a beautiful entry foyer with tile floors and vaulted ceilings. Large open great room w...

  • Beds 4
  • Baths 3.0
  • MLS 201418694

42 Brown Road Unit 42, Santa Claus IN 47579

$5,000

42 Brown Road Unit 42, Santa Claus

Free Holiday World tickets and pool available for owners. $120 a year association fee.

  • Beds
  • Baths
  • MLS 201418213

567 Ornament E, Santa Claus IN 47579

$146,500

567 Ornament E, Santa Claus

This Beautiful 12 year old Home has 1,476 sq. ft. of finished living area - 3 BRs - 2 full bath -2 car garage with bar area - formal dining room - breakfast area - gas lo...

  • Beds 3
  • Baths 2.0
  • MLS 201418447

398 Star Drive, Santa Claus IN 47579

$339,000

398 Star Drive, Santa Claus

This one of a kind, gorgeous home sits on 2 lots, with 2724 sq. ft., 3 bedrooms and a bonus room up stairs, and a extra room for an office. Master bath features a deep j...

  • Beds 4
  • Baths 3.0
  • MLS 201418205

417 Donder Lane, Santa Claus IN 47579

$199,900

417 Donder Lane, Santa Claus

Ranch with Basement on a nice level lot near recreation center. This home has lots of space with 4 bedroom, 3 bath, 2 family rooms, and a basement. Features include a m...

  • Beds 4
  • Baths 3.0
  • MLS 201418144

Silent Lane Unit 123, Santa Claus IN 47579

$5,000

Silent Lane Unit 123, Santa Claus

Wooded lot on corner of Silent Lane and Rudolph Lane with trees for privacy. Just a few minutes away from the automatic gate off Highway 162 in Santa Claus. Christmas L...

  • Beds
  • Baths
  • MLS 201417576

212 Pine Drive, Santa Claus IN 47579

$217,000

212 Pine Drive, Santa Claus

A great lakefront with a lot of space for a primary or secondary home on Christmas Lake. House features 4 bedrooms, 3.5 bath, floor to ceiling stone wood burning firepla...

  • Beds 4
  • Baths 4.0
  • MLS 201417250

931 Donder Ln, Santa Claus IN 47579

$110,100

931 Donder Ln, Santa Claus

Close to Lake Holly this 3 bedroom 2 bath home sits on level lot and offers 1575 square feet. Super nice home for the price.

  • Beds 3
  • Baths 2.0
  • MLS 201417001

1010 Balthazar Dr, Santa Claus IN 47579

$8,000

1010 Balthazar Dr, Santa Claus

Perfect lakeview lot for your dream home and enjoy all the amentities Christmas Lake Village has to offer.

  • Beds
  • Baths
  • MLS 1011416

519 Ornament Circle Unit 221, Santa Claus IN 47579

$5,500

519 Ornament Circle Unit 221, Santa Claus

Large corner lot in quiet neighborhood

  • Beds
  • Baths
  • MLS 201416377

559 E Sleigh Bell Dr, Santa Claus IN 47579

$299,000

559 E Sleigh Bell Dr, Santa Claus

Attention Golfers - Unique design one story all Brick Home on #4 Fairway of Christmas Lake Golf Course featuring 4 Bedrooms - 3 Full Baths - 2 Gas Logs Fireplaces and a 2...

  • Beds 4
  • Baths 3.0
  • MLS 201415897

Prancer Dr, Santa Claus IN 47579

$25,000

Prancer Dr, Santa Claus

There are two gorgeous lot's right across from the Rec center in the Christmas Lake Village. You can buy them together or separate. There are awesome views of the main la...

  • Beds
  • Baths
  • MLS 201415812

Prancer Dr Unit 235, Santa Claus IN 47579

$16,000

Prancer Dr Unit 235, Santa Claus

None

  • Beds
  • Baths
  • MLS 201415810

874 Sled  Circle Unit 93, Santa Claus IN 47579

$6,500

874 Sled Circle Unit 93, Santa Claus

None

  • Beds
  • Baths
  • MLS 201415622

1039 Balthazar Dr, Santa Claus IN 47579

$119,900

1039 Balthazar Dr, Santa Claus

*****Motivated Sellers******This house is a must see for price, location, and updates. House is a great price per square foot. House is across the road from Golf Course a...

  • Beds 3
  • Baths 3.0
  • MLS 201415190

302 Melchoir Dr N, Santa Claus IN 47579

$12,900

302 Melchoir Dr N, Santa Claus

***2 Lakeview Lots of Christmas Lake*** Located near Boat Docks in Evergreen Subdivision. Enjoy All of The Fabulous Amenities of Christmas Lake Village Including 3 Lakes ...

  • Beds
  • Baths
  • MLS 951025

1051 Melody Ln, Santa Claus IN 47579

$9,900

1051 Melody Ln, Santa Claus

***1 Golfcourse Lot in Christmas Lake Village*** Located in Santa's Fairway Subdivision. Enjoy All of The Fabulous Amenities of Christmas Lake Village Including 3 Lakes (...

  • Beds
  • Baths
  • MLS 951026

Madonna Drive, Santa Claus IN 47579

$4,000

Madonna Drive, Santa Claus

Enjoy all of the fabulous amenities of Christmas Lake Village including 3 lakes (Christmas Lake, Lake Holly, & Lake Noel); a beach/swimming area; a huge park with a baske...

  • Beds
  • Baths
  • MLS 201414970

303 Evergreen Plaza N, Santa Claus IN 47579

$499,900

303 Evergreen Plaza N, Santa Claus

***Lakeview home on over 1.5 acres in Christmas Lake Village*** Custom quality 4 bedroom, 4 full bath, 2 half bath, over 5300 sq ft, and finished walkout basement. Home f...

  • Beds 4
  • Baths 6.0
  • MLS 201414751